• Zum Inhalt springen
  • Zur Seitenspalte springen

Technik News

Das Blog zu IT, Mobilfunk & Internet

Rants

Macs DO crash, and aren’t that good at maths

August 24, 2006 von Franz Hieber

Today I am really peeved with my MacBook Pro. This is the second time I start this post, thanks to the almighty never-ever-hangs-honestly OS X. I intended to write a short diatribe about how remaining time for various things is not calculated right.

Let’s get the first part over with. Just before the crash, I woke up the Mac from suspended animation, and surprisingly, the battery monitor reported 158:34 hours of battery life remaining…whoa! Lets assume the average battery life of 3 hours corresponds to a battery capacity of 4Ah (Ampere-hours) – then my Mac carries a 118Ah battery. For reference, your run-of-the-mill car battery has around 70Ah. Go figure.

The second time miss-calculation happened when I extracted an archive with StuffIt, which told me I had over 300 hours to wait…when the file size was only 2MB. I will try to take screenshots next time. It is obvious that these are dumb figures, but one has to wonder why there isn’t a top limit on the values, mainly so that it doesn’t look ridiculous.

Now, for the fuming rant. I am heading back home on the bus, and to kill time, I decided to write this post. To connect to the internet while on the move, I use a Nokia N70 over Bluetooth, which gives me 3G speed (you at the back, stop giggling!). Suddenly, and before I had time to click ‘Save and Continue Editing’ for the first time, the connection froze. I tried to disconnect, and Internet Connect remained stuck on “Disconnecting…”. There was no way to get it to actually finish the disconnection process…then I noticed the N70 was actually frozen too! Cursing my luck, I removed the battery from the phone, switched Bluetooth off on the Mac, tried to kill Internet Connect using the terminal…nothing. Whether the Mac froze the N70 or the other way around is unknown, but it is clear that both have a serious flaw for this to happen.

Shutdown time. I copy-pasted the text I had written into TextEdit, and saved it to the desktop. Then, without closing TextEdit, I tried to restart the Mac, but it was having none of it. As a last attempt, I held the power button down for five seconds, and finally, it shut down. The surprise came after restarting – the text file was gone from the desktop, and with it my half-written post. There was no trace of it anywhere, neither in Finder’s nor in TextEdit’s recent file list…Is this a serious problem?

I admit that so far, the Mac has proven very stable, with very few problems, and minor ones at that. But if it is possible to have incidents like the one I experienced, then the message about how Macs are un-crashable is simply not true. I know that Robert Scoble had a similar problem with a machine just like mine, his post relating to Dave Winer’s crash report. In my case, the damage wasn’t that great, but imagine this happening towards the end of a long process, like encoding a long video edit. Mac accolites will surely say “But Windows crashes too!”. I’d answer “But Microsoft doesn’t go around publishing agressive campaigns saying how Windows PCs are rock-solid in comparison with the monkey-on-acid-squeek-of-death”.

I love my Mac. But I disagree with the hype.

My last day as a Fonero – bye FON, hello future

August 1, 2006 von Harald Puhl

Today is my last day as a Fonero, which is the way people registered in FON’s network are called (IMHO a rather ugly name). Why this decision? There are a number of reasons, and I have chosen to simply make a list.

  • The most important reason is that I have taken a position at a company that makes it unethical for me to continue participating in FON. I will no longer post on their forums; however, I will continue to post my thoughts about FON on my blog, and replying to Martin Varsavsky in his blog when I see it appropriate.
  • FON has been a downhill experience from day one. I ordered my “social” router, and got charged by PayPal, but no confirmation from the company, no tracking number, nothing. I emailed their support address, no reply. It eventually arrived, admitedly faster than the month or two some people were reporting on the forums. After a few futile attempts at configuring the router to work with my DSL line, and a couple of completely ignored emails to FON support, I simply gave up. The router is now waiting for a PCB to turn it into a WaRThog.
  • Every time I see a new crazy idea in Martin’s blog I feel more depressed about the FON project – does he really think WiFi is the way for homeless people to make a living, reselling VoIP services over Bluetooth? (don’t ask!). Where would he send them the money? Then there are the times when he takes a product and claims it was designed by FON, sometimes in secret collaboration with his backers Skype or Google. The latest is the Skype-compatible WiFi phone made by an Accton subsidiary – this is a design that Accton started way before FON even saw it, and way before Martin could have his logos photoshopped onto the mockups. As a matter of fact, out of the box this phone will not work at FON hostspots, as it lacks the browser required to perform user login – so they will have to work some magic.
  • The english and spanish forums are another source of disappointment, with daily posts from people complaining about the extremely poor support that FON is providing them. Some have even taken to posting comments on Martin’s blog to air their issues, something blogtiquette considers a no-no. I posted a few days ago about this particular issue.
  • They have followed an ill-conceived path to gaining publicity through bloggers, resulting in serious backslash from the spanish blogosphere (see here and here). Martin seems to think that by surrounding himself with top bloggers in exchange for dubious stock options or a seat in the board will get him a free ticket to stardom.
  • I believe that FON serves two purposes – one is to give a personal vehicle of shininess to Martin’s ego. See this post by Glenn Fleishman on FON’s crazy deal announcements, later called off as a lie by Speakeasy – typical example of how he manipulates a phone conversation into front-line news. Om Malik also reported on this particular issue. Martin is someone who cannot be seen as co-founding anything, but as a leader and innovator.
    Secondly, FON serves as an experiment for Skype and Google, who somehow convinced Index and Sequoia to go along. I don’t believe the two VC firms are into experiments, but FON would certainly provide good feedback to S & G about socializing WiFi, hardware distribution, and the adoption of the Bill model as a viable way to extend a WiFi network. Other stuff such as amount of logins at each location/router, number of registered users, daily passes sold, etc. would make nice colored graphs in the resulting corporate presentation.
    But, the problem is that FON is a huge fiasco in terms of hardware distribution, firmware development, public relations, and costumer support. I thus question the validity of any figures that come out of this rather expensive experiment.
  • Their firmware development process seems to be a closely guarded secret – but not for the same reasons Apple safeguards its own developments. FON started working with Brainslayer, the creator of DD-WRT, a free Linux distribution for Linksys (and other) routers. Apparently, Brainslayer was not very well treated by FON, and he parted to work in the Sputnik project, amongst other developments.
  • Just as Mark Evans did, I have voiced my concerns about FON’s business model and strategy – now that they finally launched the Bills, it looks more ill-fated than ever.

I find it really amazing how FON, with the $21.7 million they got in funding, cannot manage to hire a competent team of support personnel, outsource their obviously ill router redistribution system, and get some muscle behind the community effort. Martin Varsavsky is known in Spain for starting companies, pumping them up, and selling at the best possible gain – then leaving them behind with serious problems. Just look at what people think of Jazztel, or what troubles the Ya.com portal went through.

For me, the FON adventure is over, and a new, better adventure is starting. We will start disclosing things around the end of August, so if you want to stay updated, you are welcome to subscribe to the RSS feed.

How can FON expect to win?

Juli 12, 2006 von Harald Puhl

Today I decided to attempt a second round at configuring the router FON sent me a few days ago, since my first out-of-the-box experience hadn’t been that good. Emails to tech support unanswered, which seems to be an endemic problem, as can be seen on FON’s forums, I finally gave up.

After plugging in the WRT54GS router as briefly described in the brief manual supplied with it (a third of one side of an A4 sheet of paper), I connect to the FON_HotSpot SSID detected by the MacBook. Fire up Firefox, and I’m promptly greeted with a welcome page that states the router could not configure itself, and thus has no connection to the Internet. It shows a few scenarios that one can check for problems, also suggesting one should consult again the third-of-a-page-handbook, and, failing all this, to try manual configuration of the router.

After about an hour of changing IP addresses of the WAN and LAN interfaces (and where is the WiFi interface? or is it linked to the LAN or WAN?), I have finally given up again. I’m not a networking überguru, but I know a bit about routing and setting up IP interfaces, and this thing just managed to get on my nerves. You cannot find a clear manual with diagrams of network connectivity, setups and scenarios, a description of the theory of operation of the hotspot, and as it has been shown, sending emails to FON support is usually futile. The forums are more helpful, but not because there is a healthy bunch of FON staff there, but because a number of talented and skilled individuals have taken upon themselves the task of helping others through the ordeal.

I’m sure that a lot, if not most, users that plug in the FON router can simply connect to it, register and start surfing, but in cases like mine, where I simply have a DSL router to which I plug in the FON router and it’s supposed to work – but doesn’t – a blank void is all there is left to stare at.

Maybe a last attempt will be to flash the new release of the firmware, once they have fixed the problems in v.0.6.6.

Bottom line is that FON cannot expect to create a WiFi planet with people roaming for free on the 1 million routers they are going to distribute, once they get their logistics right, based on complex hardware that requires from either skilled operators, or very good tech support and clear setup and troubleshooting guides. A couple of days ago, someone posted on the forum that FON was a beta company. How can a company class itself in beta? It can have a service in beta, but the company must be running, if not totally smooth, at least with agility and responsiveness, fixing its problems quickly and providing first-class customer service.

  • « Vorherige Seite aufrufen
  • Seite 1
  • Seite 2
  • Seite 3

Seitenspalte

Tags

3D-Drucker Amazon AOL Apple asus memo pad Blackberry Dell DSL E-Book E-Book-Reader Ebay Elster Facebook Google Google Android Handy Hardware Hotmail IBM Internet Makerbot Microsoft mobiles Internet Netbook Prism Quantencomputer Rundfunkbeitrag Samsung samsung galaxy fame Samsung Galaxy Mega Samsung Galaxy Tab SchülerVZ Skype Smartphone Software sony xperia tablet z Suchmaschine Tablet Tintenpatronen Twitter Typo3 WebOS WhatsApp Xing Yahoo

Technik News Kategorien

Ausgewählte Artikel

LTE tilgt weiße Flecken und drückt aufs Tempo

LTE steht für Long Term Evolution und zugleich für den Vorstoß des mobilen Internets in die erste Liga der Breitband-Internetverbindungen. [...]. Heutige Angebote für mobiles Internet bringen 3,6 oder gar 7,2 MB/sec. Der Zugang erfolgt dabei meistens über einen Internet Stick der dank USB-Schnittstelle sowohl an einem Laptop wie auch am Desktop-Computer verwendet werden kann.


Externe Festplatte mit 3,5 Zoll, 2,5 Zoll oder 1,8 Zoll

Angeschlossen wird die externe Festplatte über USB, Firewire, eSATA oder einen Netzwerk-Anschluss. Vorsicht: Bei manch einer externen Festplatte stört ein lärmender Lüfter. Die kleineren Notebook-Festplatten sind 2,5-Zoll groß. Eine externe Festplatte mit 2,5-Zoll nimmt in den meisten Fällen über den USB-Anschluss Kontakt zum Computer auf und wird über dasselbe Kabel auch gleich mit Strom versorgt.

Inhaltsverzeichnis | Impressum und Datenschutzerklärung